May Day

May Day

Theresa May launched a multi-billion pound spending spree

Read more
Trained to be a Duchess

Trained to be a Duchess

Meghan Markle Was 'Trained to Be Personable' Before She Became a Duchess

Read more
A New Man Utd Deal?

A New Man Utd Deal?

Manchester United are likely to revive their £100million move for Dortmund star Jadon Sancho

Read more
Homepage / Outside MAN / Stressed parents, unhappy pensioners and teenagers - Finance Minister answers questions from public live on air
How Man City should line up vs Atalanta in the Champions League UK’s fastest home broadband with speeds of 1,104Mbps now in Manchester Man Utd news LIVE: Ed Woodward confident of completing £60m deal, new contract talks open Transfer news LIVE: £60m Maddison to Man Utd, Liverpool deal, Chelsea ‘agreement close’ Steph McGovern leaves BBC Breakfast for own Channel 4 entertainment show Prince William reveals his ‘disastrous’ mishap in the kitchen to a celebrity chef Queen Elizabeth II’s unexpected reaction to bizarre gift: ‘It’s what I’ve always wanted!’ Revealed: Why Meghan Markle’s Diana-style TV interview is ‘problematic’ for Queen Queen and Prince Charles have ‘gone out of their way’ to help ‘struggling’ Meghan Markle Camilla’s fear will prevent her joining Prince Charles on Royal Tour in Japan Footballers’ Wives To Return As Stage Musical, Creator Confirms Billy Keane: ‘Sexton is heartbroken. Last night he sent the message: ‘Gutted. Tried my best” Fianna Fáil leader Martin will not demote Lisa Chambers over phantom votes controversy Scots mum gives birth after being told cancer treatment could leave her infertile Shah Rukh Khan asks for heels to match with his Karan Johar style ‘fashionista’ jacket! Nach Baliye 9, 20 October 2019 written updates: Helen gives a retro touch, Bhumi Pednekar drop by the sets British teen on school exchange trip dies in apartment plunge horror in Spain #13YearsofDon: Farhan Akhtar gives a shout out to Shah Rukh Khan, Priyanka Chopra and the ‘best cast’ Retirement and me: ‘Worst case scenario, I’ll sell my flat’ Woman reveals contingency plan Royal fury: How Prince William was dubbed ‘scallywag’ after going missing from Highgrove Man City news and transfers LIVE early team news for Crystal Palace fixture as Stones and De Bruyne set to return The Manchester United player who can decide Liverpool FC fixture Manchester United news and transfers LIVE De Gea and Pogba injury latest ahead of Liverpool FC fixture City trader to self-employed chef – man reveals future plans after retiring from City job Furious Melania Trump fans hit out comparing her to Meghan Markle on social media Meghan Markle receives outpouring of support after heartbreaking interview Kate Middleton opens her heart during rare interview on Pakistan visit Johnson ‘close’ to reaching numbers for historic deal Absent TD voted six times in Dáil Meghan Markle and Harry were ‘wrong’ to hide Archie away – ‘What have they got to hide?’ Ole Gunnar Solskjaer tells his Man Utd side to take more risks to beat Liverpool Real Madrid boss Zinedine Zidane lifts lid on meeting Man Utd star Paul Pogba in Dubai Bride and groom struck down with salmonella poisoning at their wedding Monster who had six kids with own daughter raped child he fathered with her Bigg Boss 13 Day 19 Twitter reactions: Fans praise Asim Riaz for his performance in the task Bigg Boss 13 Day 19 Live updates: Bigg Boss stop the task as no housemate is ready to give up Kundali Bhagya 18 October 2019 written update of full episode: Karan notices Preeta in Mahesh’s room Pound US Dollar exchange rate: GBP/USD rangebound ahead of fourth “meaningful vote” Pound euro exchange rate steady as Merkel says extension unavoidable if deal fails Pension UK: These divorcees face being £77,000 worse-off – what are you entitled to? Text scam warning: Worrying message could cost you £20 – have you had the suspicious text? Watch A Bunch Of Scientists Freak Out Over A ‘Whale Fall’ On The Bottom Of The Ocean Eurozone slump: Exports down, prices up – all indicators point to economic downturn Pound/Euro Exchange: GBP/EUR falls as Juncker proclaims “no need” for Article 50 extension Universal Credit – will amount rise? How much benefits could increase by in 2020 Ujda Chaman song Twinkle Twinkle song: Sunny Singh and Maanvi Gagroo’s song fails to impress Satellite Shankar trailer: Sooraj Pancholi is back with a patriotic drama that looks decent Violent scenes show angry commuters drag Extinction Rebellion protester from top of tube train onto platform Kasautii Zindagii Kay 2: Pooja Banerjee gets emotional on receiving a warm welcome post her injury Drug deaths in Scotland hit more than 550 over last six months State pension age rises next month – will you be affected by state pension age changes? Lidl to help shoppers buy more British produce as it invests £15bn in suppliers EU-UK deal pretty much done, awaits UK government approval – EU sources Pound US dollar exchange rate: GBP/USD rises on hopes for a Brexit extension Friend of alleged rape victim says she heard woman moaning and saying the word ‘harder’ during sex, court told Princess Eugenie reveals heartwarming nickname for mum Fergie in emotional Instagram post Princess Eugenie’s surprise confession as she admits what her favourite radio station is Man Utd plan to explore transfers for five players in January but know they could fail Man Utd suffer David De Gea injury blow just days before Liverpool Premier League clash Kate Middleton caught in embarrassing royal faux pas on first day of Pakistan tour – VIDEO Prince Harry breaks down into tears mid-speech as he recalls Meghan Markle pregnancy news Kate Middleton snub: William under fire for ‘gentleman’ protocol breach with rickshaw ride Manchester United news and transfers RECAP David de Gea injured for Spain and Paul Pogba injury news Edwin van der Sar reveals he could have joined Liverpool FC before signing for Manchester United Man City news and transfers RECAP Sterling latest plus De Bruyne, Aguero and Stones injury update Coinbase chief blasts US Senate over Libra letters Nicola Sturgeon to demand second Scottish independence referendum next year Housefull 4: Akshay Kumar, Bobby Deol caught sleeping on the sets in this BTS video Local shop is trashed in ‘ram raid’ robbery attempt Guddan Tumse Na Ho Payega 15 October 2019 Written Update of full episode: Guddan to change her name to Antara for Alisha Thor: Love and Thunder director makes a huge revelation about Natalie Portman’s character Brexit alert: No deal could spark global financial crisis, warn economic experts How much is the new state pension? What is required to get the full amount Pound US Dollar exchange rate: Brexit sees pairing slump more than 1 percent ‘We feel that’s pretty strange’ – Johnny Sexton hits out at ‘negativity’ around Ireland’s World Cup campaign Taoiseach told snap election must follow a deal on Brexit SNP has taken significant step in tackling Scotland’s horrendous drug-death toll Toofan: Farhan Akhtar suffers a ‘hairline fracture’ while shooting for the film – view pic Islamic State supporters escape Kurdish camp in Syria as Turkish forces advance Dolittle Trailer: The Robert Downey Jr starrer looks like a joyride for kids and adults alike Housefull 4 star Pooja Hedge takes a day off on her birthday to spend time with her closed ones Retirement and me: Man reveals struggle as he explains ‘I’ve no intention of retirement’ Huge emergency services response after man was stabbed in Piccadilly Gardens State pension age change: Hope for 50s women as tens of thousands raised to fight scandal Princess Margaret: Unearthed letter reveals Peter Townsend split not all as it seemed Royal shock: The huge role Prince Louis will take on next year revealed – ‘He’s ready’ Meghan Markle book ‘in the offing’ as feared biographer reveals new plans Man Utd fans all say the same thing after last-minute Kepa horror show against Norway Man Utd reach verbal agreement with Mario Mandzukic as Juventus make demand – EXCLUSIVE The Chase star Jenny Ryan stuns with her big voice on Celebrity X Factor Doggy friends of stolen Boston Terrier Ralph join campaign to ‘bring him home’ Prince William reveals secret passion he inherited from Charles – ‘It’s deep in my heart’ Sonu Ke Titu Ki Sweety actors Kartik Aaryan and Sunny Singh reunite for Pati Patni Aur Woh Gel Manicures Look Good, But What’s The Damage To Your Nails? Bigg Boss 13: Who is the biggest player between Devoleena and Paras? Vote now! Kumkum Bhagya 12 October 2019 Preview: Abhi determines to put Rishi behind bars Prince William surprises England fans by watching Czech Republic football game in pub Scots rugby fans slam chiefs after Japan matches cancelled due to typhoon season Scot travels 540 miles to save lamb she ‘regretted selling for slaughter’ Rúaidhrí O’Connor: ‘Joe Schmidt’s legacy is on the line – Ireland owe it to themselves to win well’

Outside MAN

Stressed parents, unhappy pensioners and teenagers – Finance Minister answers questions from public live on air

Straight face: Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe presents Budget 2020 at Government Buildings in Dublin. Photo: Lorraine O’Sullivan/Reuters
Straight face: Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe presents Budget 2020 at Government Buildings in Dublin. Photo: Lorraine O’Sullivan/Reuters
Kevin Doyle

STRESSED parents, unhappy pensioners and teenagers seeking more climate action told Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe that his budget did little to help them today.

The annual ‘phone in’ on RTÉ’s Today with Sean O’Rourke programme suggests many people feel Budget 2020 will not make their lives easier.

Mr Donohoe opened by defending the €6-per-tonne hike to carbon tax, saying that he hopes the Government are “winning the argument”.

He said “gradual moves” are needed and that his decisions have been “informed by the water charges”.

“I’m informed by the experience of what it’s like to have consensus for change by many but not being able to deliver on it and the consequences that has for infrastructure,” he said

Fifth year pupil Jane Prendergast from New Ross, Co Wexford complained that the minister missed an opportunity to introduce levies on single use plastics.

“Nothing was done in this year’s budget,” she said.

Mr Donohoe responded that plans are in pace to reduce plastic use in the public sector – but the issue needs to be controlled on an EU level.

Big spender: The Finance Minister has gone from Prudent Paschal to Determined Donohoe. Photo: Gerry Mooney

“We’re now working with the EU to see how this issue can be tackled across country.

“Ultimately I believe there are other ways to reduce the use of plastic rather than putting a tax on them for now,” he said.

Over the course of an hour, Mr Donohoe heard from a number of carers who feel they were not considered in the Budget.

Treacy Carroll told how she had to give up work to take care of her child Willow, who has a brain injury.

However, as a result of her husband’s income she does not qualify for the carers’ allowance.

“Instead of means testing, look at the area of needs testing,” she urged.

“I couldn’t pay somebody to work the hours that I work.

“If I was to work in the labour force it would be against the law, what I do.

“Look at what I’m saving the State, day in and day out,” Treacy said.

Mr Donohoe said there isn’t anything he could ever do in a single budget to compensate people in this situation.

He pointed to the non-means tested domiciliary allowance as a payment available regardless of income – but admitted he hadn’t been increased in the Budget.

“We need to keep at it,” he said.

Nuala Donlan argued that the Government should have stopped funding the greyhound industry to the tune of €16.8m and given the money to carers instead.

“I’m thinking this morning of all the carers’ around the country who open up the papers this morning and see there is nothing for them,” she said.

Mr Donohoe said the overall budget for carers is €1.4bn.

A caller named Christopher criticised the minister for not taking more action to help “the hidden heroes of our economy”.

He said his children in their 20s and 30s work hard but “unlike myself it seems they have got a bum deal on housing”.

“In this budget you haven’t given a cent in tax relief to the victim of your housing policy,” Christopher said, adding that young people are paying “vicious rent”.

Mr Donohoe said he didn’t bring in a tax relief for renters as it could spur landlords to up their prices further.

He noted that the Help-to-Buy scheme has been extended and “progress” is being made on home building.

Cycling was raised by Clara Clarke who said the extra €9m for next year was insufficient.

“I don’t want to be terrified. I do want to continue cycling but you’re making it hell for people who want to cycle,” she said while calling for “radical change”.

The minister said the €9m was on top of the €146m already available for cycling.

“One of the things that I will do is that if we have an opportunity to increase carbon pricing in the future is use some of the money out of that to make more progress,” he said.

Jon Williams questioned why the Government added 50 cent to the price of a packet of cigarettes but didn’t tax vaping.

Mr Donohoe said e-cigarettes don’t contain tobacco and therefore don’t fall under normal excise rules.

“The EU is now reviewing the law in this area. I do have concern regarding the long-term public health impact of vaping,” Mr Donohoe said.

Online Editors

Post a Comment